What does John 1:19 mean?
Here begins a conversation between John the Baptist and local religious leaders. As in the rest of his gospel, when John uses the term "the Jews," he generally means the high-level political and religious leaders. The ones involved here are the ultra-legalistic Pharisees (John 1:24). Pharisees were extremely devout but tended to be cold and arrogant. Not all were that way, as shown by Nicodemus (John 3:1–2), a Pharisee who apparently became a believer (John 19:39).It was fair for the Pharisees to question John the Baptist. In fact, it was exactly what they should have done. Israel's religious leaders were supposed to be the guardians of the truth. Ancient Jerusalem shared many of the same quirks as large cities do today. There were plenty of people spouting spiritual babble. John's ministry must have been quite popular or challenging to attract official investigation. Investigating a strange message was a good step, but their search doesn't seem to be very sincere.