What does Judges 11:9 mean?
For the first time in this discussion (Judges 11:4–8), Jephthah introduces the topic of the Lord's will over Israel's defeats and victories. In the previous chapter, the people of Israel asked God to deliver them from their oppressors. The Lord said no, but then the people put away all their idols and began to serve the Lord again (Judges 10:10–16). Jephthah, at least, expresses that whether he succeeds or fails in leading Gilead to victory over Ammon will be the Lord's doing, not his.Still, he wants the leaders of Gilead to be clear. If he returns to Gilead and the Lord gives him victory over the Ammonites, he intends to be leader over the elders of Gilead, as well as the inhabitants, as they had said in the previous verse. In short, Jephthah expects to become governor—or a local king, though no such label is attached. Regardless of the term used, he wants a guarantee that he will rule over all of them, despite how they helped drive him away and that he has been a leader over "worthless" men up to this point.