What does Matthew 19:3 mean?
Jesus and His disciples are on the east side of the Jordan River, likely in the region of Perea. Large crowds have followed Him there, and He continues to heal those who come to Him. Some of the Pharisees have found Jesus there, as well. Their goal is to discredit Jesus before the people or to find some reason to accuse Him of heresy. They continue to come up with questions to test Him in this way.These Pharisees ask Jesus if it is lawful, under the law of Moses, for a man to divorce his wife for "any cause." In other words, can a man divorce his wife just because he wants to?
Divorce is a sensitive topic in every era, and Jesus knows this is a trap. For one thing, John the Baptist had been arrested by Herod Antipas for challenging that ruler's divorce from his wife and remarriage to his brother's wife (Matthew 14:3–12). John was eventually executed not far from where Jesus was now. Talking about divorce in the context of Israel's rulers was clearly dangerous.
For another thing, the Pharisees drove public opinion on when and if divorce was lawful. Both leaders and the people were divided into two views. Both groups said it was lawful for a man to divorce his wife, but they disagreed on what grounds. One group insisted the wife must be guilty of significant indecency or immorality. The other group said only that the husband could divorce his wife if he was unhappy with her for any reason, at all. In this era, it would not have been considered lawful for Jewish wives to initiate a divorce under normal circumstances. The Pharisees were trying to get Jesus to choose a side in this religious and social debate.
Finally, the question was a trap for the same reason some pastors avoid the topic today: Many of those listening to Jesus were very likely divorced and remarried. Apparently, even many of the Pharisees themselves had been divorced, according to historians. Almost any answer would fail to sit well with at least some people.
Matthew 19:1–12 is Jesus' response to a question from Pharisees about divorce. After establishing that marriage was designed to be lifelong by God at creation, Jesus insists that divorce is unlawful except in the case of sexual immorality. The disciples suggest it would be better not to marry, at all, in that case. Jesus says that is not true, and a life of celibacy is only for certain people, such as eunuchs of various kinds.
Pharisees ask Jesus if it is lawful for a man to divorce his wife for any cause. Jesus reminds them marriage was designed by God at creation. Divorce, then, is lawful only in the case of sexual immorality. A rich young man asks Jesus what good thing he must do to have eternal life. Jesus insists only God is good. He challenges the man's sincerity by asking him to give all his wealth to the poor and follow Him. The man's refusal demonstrates how easy it is to prefer wealth to dependence on God. In response to the disciples' question, Jesus says salvation is impossible with men but not with God.