What does Matthew 23:23 mean?
Jesus launches into the fourth or His seven "woes" against Israel's religious leaders, the scribes and Pharisees. These are more than just a performance review, or a debate-style attack against Jesus' opponents. These are pronouncements of judgment. They come from the Son of God against those entrusted by God with the religious and spiritual leadership of His people.After calling them hypocrites once again (Matthew 23:13, 15), Jesus describes what may be the heart of the Pharisees' problem when it comes to their practice of Judaism. Over time, Jewish leaders developed a system of intricate details meant to "protect" people from accidentally breaking one of God's commandments. Men like scribes and Pharisees pour intense energy into obeying the smallest details of these traditional, manmade rules. At the same time, they are missing the point of the actual God-given laws which inspired their traditions. They are blind to the heart of God for His people.
The Israelites were commanded to tithe—give ten percent of—certain specific crops. This included oil, grain, and wine (Deuteronomy 14:22–29). Leviticus 27:30–32 goes a bit further, specifying seed of the land, fruit from trees, and animals from the herds. The Pharisees had chosen to apply this requirement to even the tiniest of the garden plants, including mint, dill, and cumin. Jesus does not condemn their choice. In fact, He says that aspect of their obedience is legitimate. At the same time, it is an example of the exacting lengths the Pharisees went to—and imposed on the people—to try to be legalistically perfect.
In focusing on these details, the Pharisees became insensitive to the greater point of those laws. Obedience was important, of course, but just as important is to know the purpose the regulations given by God. Only by knowing the purpose can a person rightly judge (John 7:24) how to apply those laws. The Lord intended for His people to live in justice, mercy, and faithfulness. Without those end goals, all the rules became mere religious exercise instead of a way to accomplish the will of God for His people.